I'm just not necessarily sold that sort of genre would be particularly bad in a game as long as everyone had buy-in. After all, we tend to have certain expectations of what genres properly are represented in graphic novels and such in this country, but a much wider range are done that way in Asia. There's a lot of embedded expectations about how an RPG plays out, and that colors what genres its used for, but that doesn't tell me it couldn't be successfully and effectively used for others if people were genuinely interested in trying.
