I voted for #1 but if possible I'd make two changes to it:
1. Somehow scoop the much-better Strahd imag (the face, anyway) from #2, size it down to the same size as the Strahd in #1, and insert it to replace what's there.
2. Make some changes to the header:
- - 2a. Lose the red "D&D"; it already says Dungeons and Dragons at the bottom
- - 2b. Make the word "RAVENLOFT" red (same shade as the D&D is now) instead of white
- - 2c. Move the whole header to the left by just enough to expose the castle; the upper part of the image is too right-heavy as it sits.