Good alternatives to proper miniatures?

One cheap-and-dirty DIY method is to take some index cards (or any comparable weight paper/cardstock, preferably white), draw stick figures of whatever you need "minis" for at whatever size you like (too big is a storage nuisance, too small is hard to handle), clip them out with so they're twice as tall as desired and have a bit of room below the feet of the art, fold them together just above the art and fold the bottom parts outward to form a base. Use some clear tape or white glue to hold the standee together.

You can either leave it at that or go get some washers or pennies or POGs and stick the standees on them with either tape (double-sided works best) or superglue so they're weighted and don't fall over so easily or get blown away when you sneeze/laugh. Probably wise to number your standees as you do the art. Up to you whether you color them, either with pens or crayons. If you want to get fancy, draw a front and back image for each subject in a head-to-head position so they'll both be upright when you fold the strip into a standee. Can't recall if the 5 Units Of Distance From Location games care about facing or not, but if they do you're covered that way.

You can do dozens of the silly things at once, and they're easy to replace if the get lost/damaged. You can even re-use the bases, and if you used pennies they have guaranteed real-world value. I've played entire seasons of Bloodbowl with standee teams, using double-sided art with little smiling faces on one side and X for eyes on the flip side so we could tell who was just down and who was stunned.

If that's too much work, just use flat counters. If you want them heavier than index card stock, finish a box of cereal or similar product and white-glue your art to the waste cardboard instead of recycling it.

If all that's too minimalist, go haunt ebay or minis sites like Lead Adventure Forum or the kajillion facebook groups and pick up bargain lots when you see them. Minis are frequently cheaper than pro RPG pawn sets are, especially if they're badly painted or just unloved. As long as you avoid older/rarer stuff the collectors are after even GW figs show up dirt cheap pretty often, often with atrociously inept paint jobs.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

TiQuinn

Registered User
I'm looking to play some Five Leagues From the Borderlands (a kind of RPG+skirmish game mashup), but I am poor and cannot drop a lot of money on proper miniatures. What are some cheap alternatives? I'm aware of Pathfinder pawn boxes, which may be the most cost effective alternative for me, but I'm not exactly sure what box to buy if I want a good mix of NPCs and monsters. Does such a box set exist. Then I found these, which look cute and functional. There's also Arcknight stuff, but it seems just as pricey as actual minis. Finally, I see that there's a Savage Worlds Fantasy Pawns Set that seems to cover a lot of ground (NPCs and monsters), but I'm not familiar enough with them to know how they stack up to some of these other options in terms of quality. What would you recommend I seek out?
My quick and dirty mini collection consists of finding a picture of the monster, shrinking it down to scale, cutting it out with a one inch hole punch, and then attaching it to the glue end of a one inch furniture pad.

Massively cheap and works extremely well.
 


Lots of good advice here.

I'm going to suggest seeing if you can find a cheap copy of Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion to steal parts from. At one point places like Amazon and Target had it for as low as $15, but those days may be gone. It has a good selection of cardboard standees and 4 plastic character figures. On top of that, it doubles as a really good 4e-ish tactical combat game on its own.

You can also use dice to stand in for enemies, using any combination of type, color, and value to help symbolize different things. D6s can be minions, with D12s as bosses, green for orcs, black for undead, etc with the numbers just being indicators to keep track of them. All sorts of options there.

Oh, another option is to go hop in the time machine and grab one of those D&D creature campaign sets from Ollies for $3...
 

jdrakeh

Front Range Warlock
Gummy Bears and M&Ms work great. I like the M&Ms for monsters so you can have goblins be red ones and orcs be the green ones and the ogre is the peanut one. Bonus is when you kill it, you can eat it.

This is how "gelatinous bears" ended up as a monster in most of my fantasy settings (different colors/flavors also typically have different abilities). :)
 

Milieu

Explorer
If you have a pound store (or nation-appropriate equivalent) in your area, it's always worth browsing the toys section. You can often find bags of, i.e., army men, or animal figurines, or dinosaurs on sale there. Not particularly appropriate for a fantasy game necessarily, but useful as basic representations of NPCs and monsters.
You say that, but that's exactly how we got iconic D&D monsters like the Bulette, Rust Monster, Owl Bear, and Umber Hulk. Turns out they're knockoff Ultraman monsters!

“There once was an unknown company in Hong Kong that made a bag of weird animal-things that were then sold in what once were called dime stores or variety stores for like $.99. I know of four other very early monsters based on them. Gary and I talked about how hard it was to find monster figures, and how one day he came upon this bag of weird beasts…He nearly ran home, eager as a kid to get home and open his baseball cards. Then he proceeded to invent the carrion crawler, umber hulk, rust monster and purple worm, all based on those silly plastic figures. The one that I chose was known in the Greyhawk campaign as “the bullet” (for it’s shape) but had only amorphous stats and abilities, not being developed. Gary told me to take it home, study it, and decide what it was and what it could do.”
—Tim Kask, 1st editor of Dragon
1720888489523.jpeg
RustMonster.jpg
1720888477555.jpeg
 



jdrakeh

Front Range Warlock
Heck, use candy - M&Ms and Skittles for small things, larger and larger candies for bigger targets.

Players get to eat what they kill.

Well, I will probably be playing it solo most of the time and, as a diabetic, eating all of those monst... er... candies probably wouldn't do me any favors. ;)
 


Voidrunner's Codex

Remove ads

Top